home insurance company review

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Review: What the Consumer Data Says

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance is a Florida-based insurance carrier with moderate customer reviews and rates. Founded in 1997, it now serves 18 states. In Florida, the company has approximately 9.7 percent of the homeowners insurance market share, and it sells home insurance through agencies and direct to consumer.

This Universal Property and Casualty review will use consumer data, including customer reviews and NAIC complaint scores, to gauge whether it's the best home insurance company for serving Florida homeowners. We will compare the data directly to Kin so you can see how each company measures up on the most important metric: customer satisfaction. 

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance vs. Kin on Customer Reviews

Universal Property and Casualty Insurance's Google reviews average 3.6 out of 5. As you can guess based on that score, the reviews are mixed: some folks are content and others are really unhappy. After reading the reviews, some trends start to emerge. 

The five-star Google reviews point out individual representatives who were “kind and considerate” to work with. But it doesn’t take long to see the one-star reviews overwhelmingly cite issues with claims. The negative reviews report a lack of communication and slow claims processing. One review reported a water leak claim had been open for 90 days and it still wasn't settled. 

Reviews in response to Hurricane Irma are mixed, too. In total, more than half of the 35 reviews that cited the hurricane mentioned extremely bad experiences dealing with claims.

By contrast, Kin's customer reviews average 4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot. Customers tend to overwhelmingly cite our team's expertise and the ease with which they got insured. Like other insurance companies, our reviews note specific agents folks worked with and how pleasant and professional they were. One reviewer even noted we beat the competition’s price by $500 and increased their coverage in doing so. 

Take a look at the average customer review scores for Kin vs. Universal Property and Casualty:

up&c customer reviewBottom line: Universal Property and Casualty offers a mixed claims experience for many customers. 

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Complaint Score

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) created the Complaint Index to assess whether an insurance company experiences more customer complaints than the norm. It's expected that some folks will get upset or feel dissatisfied when claims are denied, so the index takes into account how large the company is and its market share to determine if the complaints are above average. 

The national median complaint score is 1, and it's the baseline for all scores. If a company’s complaint score is 0, it means the company has fewer complaints than expected for its market share. Scores higher than 1 suggest the company has a higher-than-expected number of complaints. 

Universal Property and Casualty has a complaint score more than six times the national median at 6.33. This suggests that the company has many more complaints for a company of its size and market share. 

Take a look at how Universal Property and Casualty compares to Kin on customer complaints.

NAIC complaint score fo up&cUniversal Property & Casualty Insurance vs. Kin on Average Premium

The cost of homeowners insurance is always a big consideration when choosing a home insurance company. You  don't want to overpay for coverage, but you also don't want to underinsure your home.

Price is where we tend to really outshine competitors like Universal Property and Casualty. Our average premium is $1,354; theirs is $1,932 to insure the same type of home. In other words, their average premium is 42 percent higher.

Average Annual Premium Comparison

Value of Home Kin Insurance Universal Property & Casualty
$300k New Build $1,354 $1,932

Keep in mind that not every homeowner insured by Kin will pay $1,354 in annual premium. Homeowners premiums vary based on location, house size, construction, claims history, and more. 

Universal Property & Casualty Insurance on Claims

A homeowners insurance policy should prove its value when you have to file a claim. Many Florida homeowners are often left disappointed when they actually need their coverage to help them recover after devastating hurricanes and floods. Customer reviews can offer a glimpse at what to expect from an insurance company's claims experience.

Universal Property and Casualty has very polarized claims reviews, suggesting that the claims experience is contingent on the claims representative or how busy the claims department is. 

We understand that speed and communication matter when handling a claim. That's why we use technology to streamline claims processing to make sure your claim is settled quickly, fairly, and easily. Our Managed Repair Network ensures you are paired with licensed, insured, local contractors to get repair work done professionally and fast. 

We also get in touch with our customers after a storm. This may seem like extra work, but it's important for us to be there for you after a disaster.

Curious about how Kin can improve the homeowners insurance experience for you? Get a quote today to see how we can save you money and provide the best customer service. 

kin computer icon

Read More Home Insurance Company Reviews

Get a better look at how Kin compares to other Florida home insurance companies:

Get the Best Home Insurance from Kin

Don't settle for second best. Get a quote from Kin today!