888-487-9048
Log in

Protect your home with coverage that could save you money every year.

Typically only takes a few minutes.

Is it better to have a high or low deductible for home insurance?

Whether a high or low deductible is better for homeowners insurance depends on your financial circumstances and priorities. A deductible is a set amount of each covered claim you’re responsible for before insurance steps in. It affects both how much you’ll pay for your insurance and how much you’ll receive from a claim.

A high deductible is ideal if you want to lower the cost of your coverage and have enough emergency savings to cover a large out-of-pocket expense after a covered loss. A low deductible is better if you’re comfortable paying more for your policy to make sure that repairing sudden damage doesn’t cause a significant financial strain.

High vs. low home insurance deductible: What’s the difference?

When you file a claim for repairs or replacements, your insurance company typically subtracts your deductible from your final claim amount.

The main difference between a high and a low home insurance deductible is how much money you’ll pay out of pocket in the event of an approved claim. Another key difference is how your deductible amount will affect the cost of your policy (known as your premium). 

Pros and cons of a low deductible

Pros:

  • Lower out-of-pocket costs when you have a covered claim

  • Claim payouts for smaller repairs won’t be wiped out by the deductible

Cons:

  • Typically higher home insurance premiums 

  • May still have a separate deductible for wind, hail, or hurricane damage

Pros and cons of a high deductible

Pros:

  • Likely lower home insurance premiums

  • Could be a more affordable option long-term if you rarely file claims

Cons:

  • Higher out-of-pocket costs when you have a covered loss

  • Could cause financial stress if you need to file a claim for a major home repair

Tell us about your property

Enter the info below, and we'll show you an estimate based on averages.

Annual premium benchmark for similar homes

Want your exact price?

Get a personalized quote → Talk to a licensed agent 888-487-9048
Estimated premium ranges are based on historical HO3 and HD3 (homeowners) quotes issued by Kin between 2025/11/02 – 2026/11/01 to prospective customers in the states where Kin currently writes new business, filtered to quotes that reached a priced offer and excluding risks ineligible under Kin's underwriting guidelines.
Estimated premium ranges are based on historical HO3 and HD3 (homeowners) quotes issued by Kin between 2025/11/02 – 2026/11/01 to prospective customers in the states where Kin currently writes new business, filtered to quotes that reached a priced offer and excluding risks ineligible under Kin's underwriting guidelines. Ranges reflect the middle 50% of premiums for quotes matching the ZIP code, Coverage A band, and Coverage C band you selected; where insufficient quote history exists for your ZIP code, ranges are calculated at the county or state level. Estimates do not reflect the specific characteristics of your home, current rate filings, applicable discounts, deductible selections, or coverage endorsements, and are not a quote, binder, or offer of insurance. Actual premium and eligibility are determined only upon completion of a full quote and are subject to underwriting review. Coverage availability and pricing vary by state and are underwritten by the applicable Kin-affiliated carrier.

Learn more about how to use the home insurance calculator.

How do you choose between a high and low deductible?

Here are a few example scenarios to help you decide whether a high or low deductible may be right for you.

  • You want the cheapest policy price. If you care about getting the lowest possible home insurance premium, a high deductible can help. If you already have a home insurance policy, you may be able to increase your deductible to reduce your rate. 

  • You want to maximize your claim payouts. If you want to pay as little as possible out of pocket in the event of covered damage, a low deductible fits the bill. Your insurance company will cover a larger portion of the cost of repairs.

  • You don’t anticipate filing many home insurance claims. If you live in a low-risk area and don’t anticipate filing many home insurance claims, choosing a high deductible could offer premium savings.

  • You can pass a quick savings test. Could you cover a higher deductible from savings tomorrow without financial hardship? If so, a higher deductible could potentially save you money in the long run without risking financial hardship.

  • You have a mortgage with deductible limits. Your mortgage lender may limit how high your homeowners insurance deductible can be. If so, you’ll need a deductible low enough to meet the requirements.

  • You live where severe weather is common. If you live in a storm-prone state like Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, or Colorado, your policy may have a separate hurricane deductible or wind and hail deductible. These often apply instead of your standard deductible for storm damage and are usually a percentage of your dwelling coverage, (which insures your home’s structure). For example, a 2% wind and hail deductible on a home with $300,000 in dwelling coverage means you’d pay the first $6,000 of a covered storm claim. Before choosing a low standard deductible for peace of mind, check your storm deductible, since it may be the one you’re more likely to pay.

How deductibles affect your premium

Deductibles can impact your home insurance premium. Raising your deductible usually lowers your premiums, and lowering it typically raises your premium.

A lower deductible means your insurer would be responsible for a larger portion of a covered claim, so it charges more for the coverage. A higher deductible shifts more of the risk to you, so your premium is usually lower.

If you want to save money on home insurance, one of the most effective ways to reduce your premium is to raise your deductible. Many insurers allow you to do this at any time, not just when you renew your policy.

How much can a higher deductible save you?

How much you can save depends on several factors, including your insurer, policy details, location, current premium, and current deductible.

According to data from the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), changing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 could lower your premium up to 25%. Actual savings vary, so ask your insurer for a quote before changing your deductible.

However, a higher deductible means you’d pay more out of pocket if you file a claim for damage resulting from a covered event.

How to compare the costs of a high and low deductible

Let’s look at an example using the Triple-I data. Suppose your home insurance premium is $2,500, with a $500 deductible. Increasing your deductible to $1,000 could save you up to 25% of your premium, or $625 a year.

To see if the savings are worth the risk, divide the deductible increase by your yearly savings. The result is how many years it would take for your premium savings to add up to the higher deductible. Savings vary, so here are two possible examples:

  • If you save 10%, or $250 per year, it would take you two years to save the $500 difference in the deductible.

  • If you save 25%, or $625 per year, it would take less than one year to save the $500 difference in the deductible.

Keep in mind, though, that it’s possible you could need to file multiple claims in a one- or two-year period. Because you have to pay the deductible each time a claim is approved, this can affect your break-even period.

What’s a good deductible for homeowners insurance?

The right deductible for you will depend on a variety of factors, including your personal situation, location, and budget concerns. Generally, a good deductible is an amount you could pay from your savings without financial stress.

Triple-I reports that common deductibles run from $500 to $2,000, with $1,000 being the most commonly selected home insurance deductible amount.

Frequently asked questions

Is a $2,500 deductible good for home insurance?

A $2,500 deductible may be good for your home insurance if you need a low-cost policy, because a relatively high deductible like this often results in a more affordable policy. A $2,500 deductible may make sense if you live in an area that is less likely to have claims and have money in emergency savings to cover an unexpected claim. 

Is a $5,000 deductible high for homeowners insurance?

A $5,000 deductible for homeowners insurance is generally considered high for a deductible set at a specific dollar amount. However, percentage-based deductibles can be much higher. These are calculated based on your dwelling coverage, which is the amount that insures your home’s structure. Percentage deductibles are usually only applied to certain high-risk weather events, like hurricanes, and will be noted on your policy’s declarations page.

Does a higher deductible always save money?

A higher deductible may reduce your premium, but it won’t necessarily help you save money overall. If you choose a high deductible, you’ll be responsible for more of the cost out of pocket when you file a claim. Depending on how many claims you file and their value, you may end up spending more than the amount you saved through lower premiums. 

Can you change your deductible in the middle of your policy?

Some insurers let you change your standard deductible during your policy term, while others only allow changes when you renew your policy. Some states may also have rules that limit when certain deductible changes, like changes to a hurricane deductible, can take effect. Insurers in coastal areas may also temporarily pause policy changes, including deductible changes, when a storm is approaching.


Author

Elizabeth Rivelli

Elizabeth Rivelli

Contributing writer | Home insurance

Elizabeth Rivelli is a contributing writer at Kin and an insurance expert whose work has appeared in CNN, Forbes, Bankrate, and elsewhere.


Editor

Samantha Felix

Samantha Felix

Contributing editor | Insurance

Samantha Felix is a contributing insurance editor at Kin. Her work has appeared on The Simple Dollar, Reviews.com, Coverage.com, and more.